Hernia Mesh Recalls

FDA sign outside the agency that oversees hernia mesh recalls

Hernia mesh has been in widespread use for decades, and almost a dozen manufacturers have marketed dozens of mesh products. Many of those products have been recalled, but a recall is only part of the story. Most of the hernia mesh at the center of today’s lawsuits was never broadly recalled, and you may have a claim for compensation even if your mesh is still on the market.

This page lists the major hernia mesh recalls by manufacturer, starting with Covidien and Bard, the two companies facing claims that are still being filed today.

Free Case Review

Covidien Hernia Mesh Recalls

Covidien, now part of Medtronic, has not issued a broad recall of its Parietex, Symbotex or ProGrip meshes, and most remain on the market. FDA records show these limited recalls:

  • October 2018: Covidien recalled 7,333 units of Parietex Composite Parastomal Mesh after reports that the mesh failed several years after parastomal hernia repair, causing hernia recurrence that required more surgery.
  • January 2023: Covidien recalled 53 units of a Parietex Composite mesh because the collagen film had been placed on the wrong side of the mesh.
  • December 2010: Covidien recalled one lot of Surgipro polypropylene mesh, 132 units, because a breach in the sterile packaging could compromise sterility.

Covidien’s hernia mesh lawsuits do not depend on a recall. More than 10,000 people have filed Covidien claims, the first bellwether trial ended in an $88 million verdict in August 2026, and Covidien has not announced a settlement. See our latest Covidien hernia mesh lawsuit update.

Bard Hernia Mesh Recalls

Composix Kugel Patch

Bard’s most serious hernia mesh recalls involved the Composix Kugel patch, which uses a flexible memory recoil ring to spring open after it is implanted. In December 2005, Bard recalled 31,761 extra-large Composix Kugel patches in a Class I recall, the FDA’s most serious category, because the ring could break and cause bowel perforations or chronic intestinal fistulas. The recall was extended to other oval sizes, and in January 2007 Bard recalled another 16,603 large circular patches for the same problem.

Thousands of lawsuits over the recalled Kugel patches were consolidated in federal court in Rhode Island. In 2011, Bard agreed to pay $184 million to settle about 2,600 of them.

3DMax, Ventralex and Ventralex ST

  • December 2008: Bard recalled one lot of 3DMax mesh, 232 units, because boxes labeled for the left side could contain a right-side mesh.
  • April 2011: Bard recalled one lot of Ventralex hernia patches, 146 units, because medium patches were packed in cartons labeled small.
  • October 2011: Bard recalled one lot of Ventralex ST patches, 96 units, because medium patches were packed in cartons labeled large.

These were labeling recalls, not recalls over the safety problems alleged in the lawsuits. Bard’s current hernia mesh litigation involves polypropylene meshes such as Ventralex, Ventralight ST, 3DMax, PerFix Plug, Composix and Sepramesh, most of which were never recalled for those problems.

Bard agreed in October 2024 to settle the vast majority of its hernia mesh lawsuits. The Bard MDL is still open and new claims can still be filed, but because of the global settlement, new claims must meet newer and more demanding procedures. For that reason, we are still reviewing select Bard claims with severe injuries, such as multiple revision surgeries, extended hospitalization or bowel damage. See our latest Bard hernia mesh lawsuit update.

Hernia Mesh and the FDA’s 510(k) Process

One reason so many hernia mesh products reached the market, and later had problems, is the FDA’s 510(k) clearance process. Unlike premarket approval (PMA), which generally requires clinical evidence that a device is safe and effective, 510(k) clearance requires a manufacturer to show that its device is “substantially equivalent” to a device already on the market, called a predicate device.

  • 510(k) clearance rests mainly on comparison to an existing product rather than on new testing in patients
  • It generally does not require new human clinical trials, although the FDA may ask for clinical data
  • Predicate devices can differ in materials or design from the new product
  • Each new product can then serve as a predicate for the next, creating long chains of devices, many never tested in new clinical trials

Nearly every hernia mesh product on the market was cleared this way. For example, Bard’s Ventralex patch was cleared in 2002 based on its similarity to the Composix Kugel patch, the same product later recalled for ring breakage, and Covidien’s Symbotex mesh was cleared in 2013 based on its similarity to earlier Parietex Composite meshes. The lawsuits allege that manufacturers used this shortcut to bring meshes to market without adequately testing their long-term safety.

Earlier Atrium and Ethicon Recalls

The lawsuits over Atrium’s C-Qur mesh and Ethicon’s Physiomesh were largely resolved through settlements in 2021, but their recall histories remain an important part of the hernia mesh story.

Atrium C-Qur Mesh

C-Qur mesh is a polypropylene mesh with an Omega-3 fatty acid (fish oil) coating designed to keep the mesh from sticking to the bowel. Atrium Medical was acquired by Maquet, part of the Getinge Group, in 2011.

  • October 2012: The FDA issued a warning letter to Atrium citing sterilization validation failures and the handling of C-Qur infection complaints.
  • July 2013: Atrium recalled C-Qur products, including C-Qur Mesh, C-Qur Edge, C-Qur V-Patch and C-Qur TacShield, because the coating could stick to the inner packaging after exposure to high humidity.
  • February 2015: The U.S. Department of Justice announced a consent decree and permanent injunction requiring Atrium to shut down most operations at its Hudson, New Hampshire facility until it corrected manufacturing violations, and to pay $6 million.

About 3,200 C-Qur lawsuits in the federal MDL in New Hampshire were resolved in a global settlement signed in December 2021.

Ethicon Proceed and Physiomesh

Ethicon, a Johnson & Johnson company, recalled its Proceed Surgical Mesh several times because its layers could separate (delaminate), exposing polypropylene to the bowel:

  • January 2006: 18,270 units across many lots, for possible delamination
  • October 2010: one lot, 87 units, for possible delamination
  • February 2014: three lots, 223 units, because an incomplete package seal could compromise sterility

Ethicon’s Physiomesh Flexible Composite Mesh was cleared in 2010. In May 2016, Ethicon withdrew it from the market worldwide after registry data in Germany and Denmark showed higher rates of hernia recurrence and reoperation than other meshes. In 2021, Ethicon agreed to resolve more than 3,700 Physiomesh cases.

Does My Mesh Need to Be Recalled for Me to Have a Claim?

No. Most hernia mesh claims today involve products that were never recalled, or that were recalled only for labeling or packaging problems. What matters is the mesh you received, the complications you have had, and what your medical records show. If you had a Covidien or Bard mesh and developed complications such as bowel adhesions or obstruction, chronic pain, infection, mesh migration or a recurrent hernia, you may have a claim for compensation. Read more about hernia mesh complications.

Doyle APC currently represents clients nationwide in the Covidien and Bard hernia mesh lawsuits, and you pay nothing unless we recover.

Free Case Review

Common Questions

Has Covidien hernia mesh been recalled?

Covidien has not broadly recalled its Parietex, Symbotex or ProGrip meshes. It has issued limited recalls, including a 2018 recall of Parietex Composite Parastomal Mesh after reports of mesh failure. Covidien claims do not depend on a recall.

Has Bard hernia mesh been recalled?

Yes. Bard recalled Composix Kugel patches in 2005 and 2007 because the memory recoil ring could break, and it has issued smaller labeling recalls for 3DMax and Ventralex products. Most Bard meshes in the current litigation were never recalled for the problems alleged in the lawsuits.

Can I file a claim if my mesh was not recalled?

Yes. Most hernia mesh claims involve meshes that were never recalled. A claim depends on the mesh you received, your complications and your medical records, not on whether there was a recall.

How do I find out if my mesh was recalled?

Your operative report lists the brand, product and often the lot number of your mesh. That information can be checked against FDA recall records. If you cannot find your report, we can request your records and review them for you.

What is the difference between a Class I and Class II recall?

A Class I recall is the FDA’s most serious category, for products that could cause serious injury or death. A Class II recall involves products that could cause temporary or reversible health problems, and a Class III recall involves products unlikely to cause harm, such as labeling errors.